Temporarily suspended
| 2019 | ||
| January | Walk Two Moons | Creech, Sharon |
| February | My Side of the Mountain | George, Jean Craighead |
| March | Secret of Platform 13 | Ibbotson, Eva |
| April | Bunnicula | Howe, James |
| May | Nurk | Vernon, Ursula |
| 2018 | ||
| January | The Ice Dragon | Martin, George R. R. |
| February | The Lightning Thief | Riordan, Rick |
| March | How to Train Your Dragon | Cowell, Cressida |
| April | The Mariner’s Curse | Lunn, John |
| May | Reader’s Choice | |
| September | The Secret School | Avi |
| October | The Inquisitor’s Tale | Gidwitz, Adam |
| November | Minecraft the Island | Brooks, Max |
| December | Where the Mountain Meets the Moon | Lin, Grace |
| 2017 | ||
| January | Moon Over Manifest | Vanderpool, Clare |
| February | Nest | Ehrlich, Esther |
| March | Escape from Baxter’s barn | Bond, Rebecca |
| April | Moo | Creech, Sharon |
| May | A Hundred Horses | Lean, Sarah |
| June | The Capture: Guardians of Ga’hoole | Lasky, Kathryn |
| September | Reader’s Choice | |
| October | Island of the Blue Dolphins | O’Dell, Scott |
| November | The True Gift | MacLachlan, Patricia |
| December | The Grand Escape | |
| 2016 | ||
| January | Perloo the Bold | Avi |
| February | The Underneath | Appelt, Kathi |
| March | Same Stuff as Stars | Paterson, Katherine |
| April | Into the Wild | Hunter, Erin |
| May | Nuts to You | Perkins, Lynne Rae |
| June | Half Magic | Eager, Edward |
| July | The Running Dream | VanDraanen, Wendelin |
| September | Firstborn | Seidler, Tor |
| October | Hermit Thrush Sings | Butler, Susan |
| November | The Moorchild | McGraw, Eloise |
| December | Redwall | Jacques, Brian |
| 2015 | ||
| January | Breadcrumbs | Ursu, Anne |
| February | Chasing Vermeer | Balliett, Blue |
| March | Homeless Bird | Whelan, Gloria |
| April | Touch Blue | Lord, Cynthia |
| May | The Robe of Skulls | French, Vivian |
| June | Divergent | Roth, Veronica |
| July | Beowulf | Hinds, Gareth |
| September | A Million Ways Home | Dorisi-Winget, Dianna |
| October | Penderwicks 1 | Birdsall, Jeanne |
| November | Doll Bones | Black, Holly |
| December | The Wanderer | Creech, Sharon |
| 2014 | ||
| January | Holes | Sachar, Louis |
| February | Cosmic | Boyce, Frank Cottrell |
| March | One Crazy Summer | Williams-Garcia, Rita |
| April | Small as an Elephant | Jacobson, Jennifer Richard |
| May | Reader’s Choice | |
| September | Among the Hidden | Haddix, Margaret Peterson |
| October | The Folk Keeper | Billingsley, Franny |
| November | The Breadwinner | Ellis, Deborah |
| December | Because of Mr. Terupt | Buyea, Rob |
| 2013 | ||
| January | Escaping the Giant Wave | Kehret, Peg |
| February | 11 Birthdays | Mass, Wendy |
| March | A Blizzard Year | Ehrlich, Gretel |
| April | Oggie Cooder | Weeks, Sarah |
| June | Tuck Everlasting | Babbitt, Natalie |
| September | The One and Only Ivan | Applegate, Katherine |
| October | Wonder | Palacio, R. J. |
| November | Wonderstruck | Selznick, Brian |
| December | Watson’s go to Birmingham, 1963 | Curtis, Christopher Paul |
| 2012 | ||
| January | ||
| February | Walk Two Moons | Creech, Sharon |
| March | Seven Wonders of Sassafras Springs | Birney, Betty G. |
| April | Five Children and It | Nesbit, E. |
| May | The Penderwicks | Birdsall, Jeanne |
| Summer Reading Program | The Dreamer | Ryan, Pam Munoz |
| September | The Magician’s Elephant | DiCamillo, Kate |
| October | Reach Me | Stead, Rebecca |
| November | Mostly True Adventures of Home Figg | Philbrick, Rodman |
| December | Love Ruby Lavendar | Wiles, Deborah |
| 2011 | ||
| November | Indian in the Cupboard | Banks, Lynne Reid |
| December | My Side of the Mountain | George, Jean Craighead |
